New Book Reveals Paul McCartney's Bold Retaliation Against Critic Amid Wings Era Escapades
November 6, 2025
The journalist was accused of reporting on McCartney's family life while delivering a scathing critique of the live performance, despite reportedly not attending the show.
Seiwell relays the couple’s claim that their reaction was a form of pushback against crude press treatment, presenting it as a calculated response by Paul and Linda McCartney.
The book integrates multiple strands of McCartney-era public engagement, including a new visualizer for Band on the Run, a fresh book release, and ongoing tour activity as part of the Band on the Run legacy.
The piece notes that Harry Styles is a fan of Wings, underscoring the band’s continued influence on newer artists.
NME and ABC Audio coverage situate the anecdote within broader media context, highlighting how the story has circulated in press circles.
Wings: The Story of a Band on the Run, an oral history with photos, diaries and anecdotes, surveys the era with other Wings milestones, including anniversary editions and reissues.
The book’s overarching theme is wild, previously untold stories from Wings’ era, suggesting there are many more such anecdotes to come.
Stella McCartney contributes context on her parents’ influence and reflects on Paul and Linda’s relationship with the press alongside references to Lennon’s murder and the final positive phone call.
Represenatives and McCartney have not issued public statements about the anecdote as of publication, leaving readers to speculate on possible future responses.
The piece hints at how this and similar stories could influence perceptions of McCartney in future biopics and public retrospectives.
Overall, the piece frames the incident as emblematic lore from the McCartneys’ press battles in the early 1970s, contrasting with later reassessments of Wings.
A new oral history about Wings, Band on the Run and Paul McCartney recounts a backstage incident where a journalist who criticized a Wings concert allegedly received a retaliatory reception and a harsh, personal review, tied to a controversial gesture involving a baby-related prank.
Summary based on 37 sources
Get a daily email with more Entertainment stories
Sources

New York Post • Nov 5, 2025
Paul McCartney sent his baby daughter’s turd to a critic over a negative concert review: book

