Over the past three seasons, his power has declined, posting 12-14 homers and mid-.250s batting averages, though he remains strong defensively with elite caught-stealing and pop-time metrics.

In 2025, Realmuto hit .257/.315/.384 with 12 home runs in 134 games and totaled 129 strikeouts, highlighting age as a consideration for teams.

Bleacher Report suggests his market may be limited this offseason, with a Rangers–Red Sox bidding landscape unlikely to produce a strong deal.

Jim Bowden and others have noted interest from the Rangers and Red Sox, citing Realmuto’s Oklahoma roots as a tie to Texas and a potential two-year deal appeal.

Boston has shown interest, making Realmuto a potential option beyond Phillies ties while evaluating market dynamics.

The Athletic’s reporting also underscores that Realmuto may seek a shorter deal, a factor in how aggressively teams bid.

Texas’ offseason moves, including adding Brandon Nimmo, create a top-order boost that could pair with Realmuto if payroll allows, though financial constraints remain a factor.

The Red Sox are expected to be active, with continued interest in high-profile free agents and potential trades as they reshape the roster.

J.T. Realmuto, entering free agency after a long stint with the Phillies, is regarded as the top catcher available, bringing a career .270/.328/.447 slash line and multiple All-Star and Gold Glove accolades.

One proposed trade scenario would send Boston catcher Carlos Narváez to acquire Realmuto as the primary backstop, though this would hinge on team needs and costs.

Phillies’ offseason narrative centers on Realmuto’s status as a core piece, alongside ongoing discussions around Schwarber and other roster moves.

Boston’s spending posture, historically wary of long-term commitments, tempers Realmuto’s appeal for the Red Sox given cost and age considerations.