Uncovering the Dark Legacy of Carlisle Indian School: Deaths, Repatriations, and Lost Histories

November 6, 2025
Uncovering the Dark Legacy of Carlisle Indian School: Deaths, Repatriations, and Lost Histories
  • The Carlisle Indian Industrial School operated for 39 years, from 1879 to 1918, educating about 7,800 students from over 100 tribes, and it sits at the center of a broader national story about federally funded boarding schools.

  • Mortality at Carlisle and across government-run boarding schools remains a grave part of the legacy, with a Washington Post investigation estimating roughly 3,100 deaths and experts suggesting the true figure is higher.

  • In a sign of early dissent, a 1913 petition by 276 students called for an investigation into Carlisle’s conditions, highlighting contemporaneous concerns about the institution.

  • Recent exhumations and repatriations at Carlisle illustrate ongoing efforts to acknowledge harms, recover Indigenous remains, and restore histories.

  • Beyond Carlisle, the article notes ongoing exhumations and repatriations of remains across the federal boarding school system, signaling continued reconciliation work.

  • Across federal schools, 74 burial sites have been identified (53 marked, 21 unmarked), with 65 schools reporting incomplete counts of burial sites.

  • The identified burial sites—74 in total, including 53 marked and 21 unmarked—underscore the scale of loss within the federal boarding school network.

  • The piece weaves together institutional impact, mortality, and policy context, anchored by Carlisle and supported by broader national data.

  • Since 2017, 58 Indigenous remains have been repatriated from the Carlisle Barracks cemetery, leaving 118 graves with Indigenous names and about 20 graves still unidentified.

  • The story situates boarding schools within a vast landscape—about 526 schools historically, with 417 federally funded and others run by religious groups—highlighting government and church efforts to erase Indigenous identities.

  • Government costs to operate the schools and pursue related policies totaled about $23.3 billion in inflation-adjusted terms, spanning 1871 to 1969.

  • A central theme is the policy framework behind the schools, including 127 treaties between the U.S. government and tribes that implicate federal involvement in the program.

Summary based on 6 sources


Get a daily email with more US News stories

More Stories