Fetterman Floats Leaving Democrats if Van Hollen Wins Senate Leadership
November 14, 2026
John Fetterman said he could consider leaving the Democratic Party if the Senate caucus elects Chris Van Hollen as its leader, whom he views as hostile to Israel, though he did not say he would definitely leave and reiterated, “I am a Democrat.”
Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer for the Democratic leadership post, arguing the party needs new leadership and must address public distrust of Washington; senators are expected to vote by secret ballot in early December.
In a Saturday Fox News interview, Fetterman argued Democrats should hold Iran accountable rather than punish Israel or withhold aid, and criticized Van Hollen for directing anger at Israel instead of Iran, Hezbollah and Hamas.
Van Hollen has criticized Israel’s conduct in Gaza and supported restricting some offensive U.S. arms sales, while saying Israel has a right to defend itself and that defensive systems such as Iron Dome should continue to be transferred.
Fetterman also urged Democrats to avoid infighting and work with the White House on issues including the national debt, artificial intelligence, Iran and Social Security.
The dispute comes as Ahmed Moor, a 42-year-old democratic socialist, has launched a 2028 primary challenge to Fetterman; Moor’s campaign rejected Fetterman’s “pro-Hamas” characterization, saying Moor condemns violence against civilians and supports an arms embargo and targeted sanctions until Palestinians have equal rights.
Fetterman’s support for Israel’s military actions in Gaza, opposition to measures related to the Iran war, and votes with Republicans to end a government shutdown and confirm Trump appointees have increasingly set him apart from Democrats.
Fetterman has said he will not become a Republican, citing his support for labor unions and LGBTQ+ rights, even as his positions have alienated Democrats in Pennsylvania.
Fetterman has developed a close working relationship with Republican Senator David McCormick, and Senate Majority Leader John Thune said Republicans would welcome him if he switched parties; Donald Trump and Sen. Mike Lee have also publicly encouraged the idea.
His standing among Pennsylvania Democrats has weakened: a Quinnipiac University poll released the previous month found 13 percent approved of his job performance, compared with 72 percent of Pennsylvania Republicans.
As of 1 p.m. ET on November 14, Kalshi markets implied a 23 percent chance Fetterman would become the Republican Senate nominee in Pennsylvania in 2028 and a 3 percent chance he would win the Democratic nomination; these odds reflect speculative market sentiment, not polling or evidence of a decision to leave the party.
Summary based on 10 sources
Get a daily email with more US News stories
Sources

The Independent • Nov 14, 2026
John Fetterman signals he would consider quitting Democratic Party if they make ‘troubling’ majority leader pick
Newsweek • Nov 14, 2026
John Fetterman Signals Breaking Point With Democrats Over Van Hollen
Fox News • Nov 14, 2026
Fetterman warns there is no longer 'common ground' with far-left Democrats over Israel
Fox News • Nov 14, 2026
Fetterman warns there is no longer 'common ground' with far-left Democrats over Israel