Murder Charges Dropped After Sleep Disorder Defense in Camping Stabbing Case

February 4, 2025
Murder Charges Dropped After Sleep Disorder Defense in Camping Stabbing Case
  • Before dropping the charges, prosecutors indicated they were consulting with Serdar Caliskan's relatives in Turkey.

  • Caliskan was originally set to stand trial in the Victorian Supreme Court in March 2025, but the case was discontinued.

  • Ilknur Caliskan, 47, has had murder charges against her dropped following expert evaluations that suggested she may have acted involuntarily due to a sleep disorder.

  • The announcement of the discontinuation of charges was made during a brief court hearing on February 4, 2025, which Caliskan did not attend.

  • The decision to drop the murder charge followed a sleep study that raised questions about Caliskan's state of consciousness during the incident.

  • Caliskan claimed she was asleep during the incident, which occurred on September 30, 2023, while she and her husband, Serdar Caliskan, were camping near Colbinane.

  • Caliskan was released on bail in mid-2024 to undergo testing at a sleep facility in Sydney, as her defense team sought to explore parasomnia as a potential defense.

  • Parasomnia is a sleep disorder characterized by abnormal behaviors during sleep, which may explain Caliskan's actions during the incident.

  • Experts from both the defense and prosecution agreed that Caliskan could have been experiencing a sleep disorder at the time of the stabbing.

  • Serdar, aged 50, died at the scene despite paramedics' attempts to save him after being stabbed by Ilknur.

  • The prosecution initially charged Caliskan with murder after the stabbing incident during the camping trip.

  • A defense sleep expert testified that Caliskan was not acting consciously during the stabbing, while a prosecution expert could not rule out the possibility of a sleep disorder.

Summary based on 4 sources


Get a daily email with more Australia News stories

More Stories