Bitcoin Core v30 Sparks Controversy with OP_RETURN Data Limit Increase: Innovation or Risk?

October 13, 2025
Bitcoin Core v30 Sparks Controversy with OP_RETURN Data Limit Increase: Innovation or Risk?
  • This change echoes past debates from the 2017 Blocksize Wars, emphasizing the importance of community consensus in protocol updates.

  • Leaked messages suggested Luke Dashjr might consider a hard fork to counteract the data limit increase, but he denied planning any such action, criticizing the change.

  • Major updates include lowering default transaction fees, with relay fees as low as 0.1 sat/vB, and miner inclusion fees at 0.001 sat/vB.

  • The development opens new opportunities for applications like metadata storage, inscriptions, and integration into sectors such as crypto payroll and compliance.

  • After backlash, developers restored user control over OP_RETURN data limits, allowing manual adjustments, and clarified that the change affects mempool policy without altering Bitcoin’s consensus rules.

  • While some see the larger OP_RETURN capacity as enabling complex decentralized applications similar to Ethereum, purists worry it could lead to blockchain bloat and higher operational costs.

  • This update echoes past debates, such as the 2017 block size wars, highlighting ongoing tensions over Bitcoin’s scalability and purpose.

  • Overall, the OP_RETURN change is a pivotal moment that demands careful governance to balance innovation with the preservation of Bitcoin’s core principles and community consensus.

  • Supporters argue that increased data capacity can foster innovative decentralized applications and expand Bitcoin’s ecosystem.

  • Some believe the larger capacity will enable Bitcoin to support more complex applications similar to Ethereum.

  • Controversy surrounds the change, with critics fearing it could enable illegal or malicious content hosting, leading to legal issues for node operators.

  • The update marks the end of support for versions 27.x and older, emphasizing the shift to the new version.

  • Historically, limitations on block size led to Layer 2 solutions like Lightning; the OP_RETURN change could inspire similar innovations.

  • Bitcoin Core v30.0 introduces significant node-related architecture, performance, and security updates, including improved performance, bug fixes, and optional encrypted connections.

  • The release marks a major upgrade, enhancing network performance and security.

  • Bitcoin Core v30 was officially released, bringing performance improvements and architecture updates.

  • The Knots community, led by Luke Dashjr, opposes the change, arguing Bitcoin should focus on money transfer and expressing concerns about potential misuse of increased data limits.

  • Critics like Nick Szabo warn about legal risks and increased node operation costs, advocating for strict data size enforcement as a temporary measure.

  • The change aims to enable more complex applications, sparking debate within the community.

  • This update allows for new use cases such as identity management, smart contracts, and decentralized applications, broadening Bitcoin’s functionality.

  • The community is polarized, with some fearing it could undermine Bitcoin’s integrity, while others see it as necessary for innovation.

  • Critics worry that the expansion could undermine Bitcoin’s role as a peer-to-peer cash system, risking blockchain bloat and higher operational costs.

  • Szabo raised concerns about illegal data hosting, emphasizing the need for safeguards.

  • Legal risks are heightened for node operators, as larger embedded data could include illegal content like CSAM, exposing them to liability.

  • The change opens opportunities for decentralized finance, improved on-chain regulatory compliance, and increased transparency, but also raises concerns about network health and legal implications.

  • Community reactions are mixed, with purists opposing the change due to fears of blockchain bloat, legal issues, and deviation from Bitcoin's original purpose as a peer-to-peer cash system.

  • This development raises fundamental questions about Bitcoin’s core identity, with critics worried that broader data applications might dilute its primary function.

  • The update also includes fixing five low-severity bugs, with detailed bug fix information to be released soon, and marks Bitcoin Core v27.x as End of Life.

  • Legal concerns persist regarding hosting illegal data and increased node operation costs, leading some experts to advise against upgrading to v30.

  • Graphical improvements include support for dark mode on Windows, a switch from Qt5 to Qt6, and Metal graphics support on macOS for smoother performance.

  • Many node operators are already using alternative software like 'knots' to enforce data size limits, with over 21% of nodes running Knots to mitigate risks associated with the increased OP_RETURN capacity.

  • The update introduces TRUC transactions to prevent conflicts during confirmation and a new 'bitcoin' command to streamline node and miner interactions.

  • Bitcoin Core v30 no longer supports BDB wallets, requiring users to migrate to descriptor wallets, and removes commands like importwallet and dumpwallet.

  • Supporters see the larger data capacity as a way to foster innovative applications, while critics warn it could violate Bitcoin’s principles and facilitate illegal data hosting.

  • Bitcoin Core v30 has dramatically increased the OP_RETURN data limit from 80 bytes to 100,000 bytes, enabling embedding of larger non-financial data in transactions, which has sparked significant controversy.

  • However, without mechanisms to remove illegal content, node operators face legal risks, potentially discouraging participation and causing community fractures.

  • Notable critics like Luke Dashjr have voiced opposition, criticizing the update, although he has not publicly commented since its release.

  • This update allows users to attach larger data such as hashes, certificates, or art metadata, and supports multiple outputs, expanding Bitcoin's potential applications.

  • The increase in data capacity raises concerns about blockchain bloat, network inefficiency, and spam attacks, which could threaten network stability.

Summary based on 5 sources


Get a daily email with more Crypto stories

More Stories