A copyright infringement lawsuit has been filed against Parkwood and Beyoncé’s team over the song Alien Superstar from Renaissance, alleging an unauthorized sample of John Holiday’s Moonraker.

The plaintiffs say a post-release license was secured, and they seek to halt sales and pursue damages amid ongoing litigation.

Plaintiffs contend Beyoncé’s side later claimed permission from Holiday, but Holiday allegedly had already transferred his rights decades earlier, making that clearance invalid.

As of the report, no licensed or court-determined outcome exists and the dispute remains unsettled.

There are no settlement details or court dates provided, keeping the case unresolved.

This case is part of a longer legal saga around Moonraker, with prior rulings about entity formation and ownership transfers that raise risk for future projects.

The dispute underscores the complexity of sample-based rights and the potential for renewed challenges even after initial decisions.

Additional sources such as Daily Mail, TMZ, and Culted are cited for different aspects of the report.

Links to the full complaint and listening examples of the two recordings are provided for context.

The case highlights ongoing risk for major artists and labels when catalog rights are uncertain, especially for hit tracks with long revenue streams.

A judge’s ruling notes that dismissal did not resolve whether the sample was cleared or the merits of the infringement claim.

If successful for the plaintiffs, the case could reshape sampling practices, prompting more exhaustive ownership checks and alternative creative approaches.