SPD's Brosius-Gersdorf Withdraws Court Nomination Amid CDU/CSU Opposition and Misinformation Concerns
August 7, 2025
Her decision comes amid concerns over escalating conflict within the black-red coalition, which could have unforeseen consequences for democracy.
Miersch highlighted that trust in the Union has been shaken due to their inconsistent support for Brosius-Gersdorf, undermining the foundation of democratic cooperation.
The political climate indicates a growing susceptibility of the parliament and the Union faction to right-wing misinformation and panic-inducing tactics.
The SPD may face internal scrutiny regarding its delayed response to the criticism of Brosius-Gersdorf and the failure to prevent the smear campaign.
Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf, nominated by the SPD, has withdrawn her candidacy for a position at the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, citing significant opposition from the CDU/CSU faction.
Brosius-Gersdorf criticized the media for conducting a defamatory campaign against her, disputing the validity of citing anonymous sources in their reporting.
She emphasized the need for responsible practices in future elections, warning that misinformation could severely damage the integrity of the judicial appointment process.
In light of this situation, SPD General Secretary Julian Barlen criticized Peters for politicizing the Federal Constitutional Court, stressing that citizens expect solutions rather than populist campaigns.
The withdrawal has been viewed positively by some, as it may help quell the heated debate surrounding her candidacy.
The future of the coalition in filling the vacant seats on the Constitutional Court remains uncertain, as judicial appointments typically require a two-thirds majority in parliament.
This incident marks the first time a candidate has been publicly undermined after receiving a two-thirds majority in the judges' selection committee.
The situation has led to mixed reactions among political parties, with expressions of regret from the SPD, Greens, and Left parties regarding the failed nomination process.
Summary based on 42 sources
Get a daily email with more World News stories
Sources

Deutsche Presse-Agentur • Aug 7, 2025
Top German court nominee withdraws after conservative backlash
Deutsche Presse-Agentur • Aug 7, 2025
Top German court nominee withdraws after conservative backlash