It was regarded as one of the greatest courses in the U.S., attracting famous players and receiving praise for its innovative design, but ultimately was lost to development and war.

In the mid-20th century, the site thrived with glamorous hotel and resort activities but eventually declined and was replaced by condominiums, leaving little of the historic course today.

Today, the story of the Lido raises questions about preservation and whether the new course can truly replace or merely echo the romanticized legacy of the original.

The original Lido Golf Course in Long Island, designed by C.B. Macdonald in the early 20th century, was built on man-made land and became legendary despite facing financial and environmental challenges.

During World War II, in 1942, the U.S. Navy seized the Lido Hotel and Golf Course, repurposing the land for military use, which led to the course's destruction.

In 2023, a new Lido course was built at Sand Valley in Wisconsin, designed as a faithful tribute to Macdonald’s original, using detailed research and 3D modeling.

This recreated Lido is a private club with a no-alcohol policy, attracting dedicated golf enthusiasts who appreciate its historic design despite its challenging layout and absence of ocean views.

The story ultimately explores whether the essence of Macdonald’s original work still exists or if it has become a myth, depending on perspective.