Caroline Hallemann’s The Kennedys and the Windsors compares the American Kennedy dynasty with the British royal family to draw parallels and contrasts.

Overall, the book is stylish, well-researched, and engaging for casual readers, though it may leave true aficionados wanting deeper revelations or a tighter argumentative thread.

The critique comes from journalist and historian Alexander Larman, who provides the authorial perspective.

A central thesis centers on shared misfortune and tragedy in both dynasties, including JFK and RFK Jr.’s notoriety and past Kennedy scandals.

Notable crossover moments are explored, such as JFK and Jackie at Buckingham Palace in 1961 and John Jr. meeting Diana in 1995, with discussion of motives and potential tabloid angles.

Criticisms include uneven detail, with more on the Kennedys than the Windsors, and a structural rhythm of alternating chapters that can strain the connections between the two lineages.

Hallemann faces the challenge of writing about two highly studied dynasties and aims to offer fresh angles on their historical paths.

The book highlights core contrasts: Kennedy glamour and scandal versus the Windsors’ stately image and wartime leadership, such as George VI during WWII and the abdication legacy.

Publication details: The Kennedys and the Windsors: The Story of Two Dynasties, One Born, One Made by Caroline Hallemann, published by Putnam’s, 372 pages, priced at $35.