Mistaken Identity: Nacua Brothers Cleared in SUV Mix-Up Amid NFL Drama

January 16, 2026
Mistaken Identity: Nacua Brothers Cleared in SUV Mix-Up Amid NFL Drama
  • Nacua’s attorneys say the case was promptly dismissed after review and is now closed.

  • Samson Nacua’s football journey spans Utah and BYU in college, with pro stints in the UFL and brief NFL affiliations, including a one-game suspension tied to a fan incident.

  • The incident occurred amid broader pressures for Puka, including a recent $25,000 fine for criticizing NFL officials and a controversial antisemitic symbolism video for which he apologized.

  • Samson Nacua, elder brother of NFL wide receiver Puka Nacua, was involved in a December incident in West Hollywood where he and Trey Rose were arrested over an SUV taken without consent, initially attributed to a Lakers player but later identified as a mistaken belief tied to similar vehicles.

  • Investigators determined the act was a mistaken taking, with early reports of theft clarified as an honest mistake when it was shown the vehicle did not belong to Adou Thiero or Puka Nacua.

  • Puka Nacua and Thiero own similar newer-model BMWs in the same color, contributing to the confusion that sparked the incident.

  • Thiero chose not to press charges, and the case was ultimately dismissed after LASD reviewed the matter and the LA County Attorney’s Office was asked to reject the case.

  • Background notes highlight Nacua’s Utah/BYU connections and corroborating posts from sports outlets about the case.

  • Samson Nacua is set to play in the 2026 UFL season for the Birmingham Stallions, following stints with the Michigan Panthers and Pittsburgh Maulers.

  • Earlier, the UFL had suspended Nacua for one game in April for a fan-related incident.

  • Meanwhile, Puka Nacua has thrived with the Rams, leading the NFL in receptions last season and preparing for a playoff matchup against the Chicago Bears, keeping football in focus after the mistaken arrest.

  • Puka Nacua’s 2025 season featured 129 receptions and 1,715 receiving yards, underscoring his rising profile despite off-field controversies.

Summary based on 6 sources


Get a daily email with more NFL stories

More Stories