Matthew Schaefer was selected first overall by the New York Islanders in 2025, marking the latest addition to the group of highly scrutinized first picks.

Nail Yakupov, selected first overall in 2012, is considered one of the worst first overall picks, struggling to meet expectations and eventually leaving the NHL to play in Russia.

A recent article reviews the performance and future outlook of every first overall pick in the NHL Draft since 2010, highlighting the varying success levels of these players.

Macklin Celebrini, the first overall pick for the Sharks in 2024, has started his career strong and is seen as a cornerstone for the franchise's future.

Connor Bedard, anticipated as a generational talent, had a strong rookie season but faces pressure to elevate his game as the Blackhawks rebuild.

Connor McDavid, drafted in 2015, is widely regarded as one of the greatest players of his generation, excelling with numerous individual awards and leading the Oilers towards playoff contention.

Nathan MacKinnon, who was drafted in 2013, has become one of the NHL's biggest stars, winning multiple awards and helping the Avalanche secure the Stanley Cup in 2022.

Aaron Ekblad, drafted in 2014, has established himself as a key defenseman for the Panthers, although injuries have affected his performance.

Juraj Slafkovský, the first overall pick in 2022, has shown progress in his early career with the Canadiens but remains a work in progress with room for improvement.

Auston Matthews, selected in 2016, has solidified his status as the top goal scorer of his era, achieving multiple scoring titles and playoff appearances with the Maple Leafs.

Nico Hischier, the first overall pick in 2017, has evolved into a strong two-way player and captain of the Devils, contributing to their recent playoff success.

Rasmus Dahlin, who was picked in 2018, has emerged as a premier defenseman for the Sabres, showing leadership potential as he captains a rebuilding team.

Jack Hughes, drafted in 2019, has displayed flashes of stardom, becoming a key offensive player for the Devils despite injury setbacks.