Federal Prosecutor's Inquiry into Medical Journals Sparks Fears of Political Bias and Censorship
April 24, 2025
This inquiry has sparked fears regarding the Trump Administration's interference in scientific discourse and the integrity of journal practices.
Among the journals contacted, the New England Journal of Medicine received a letter addressing allegations of bias in its published research.
Critics argue that these actions undermine established scientific principles and threaten the peer-review process, potentially leading to self-censorship among journals.
The situation reflects a broader trend of the administration favoring certain narratives while marginalizing legitimate scientific discourse, raising alarms about censorship.
Federal prosecutor Edward Martin Jr. has raised concerns about potential political bias in medical publications by sending letters to at least three prominent medical journals.
The letters include inquiries about funding sources and the acceptance of competing viewpoints, with responses requested by May 2, 2025.
Dr. Eric Rubin, editor in chief of the New England Journal of Medicine, described the letter as 'vaguely threatening' and reaffirmed the journal's commitment to editorial independence and First Amendment rights.
Experts warn that political interference in scientific publishing could hinder advancements in healthcare and benefit those who profit from ignorance.
Martin's inquiries have been seen as vague threats that could limit the publication of studies that do not align with the administration's views.
This incident highlights ongoing tensions between federal authorities and medical journals regarding the integrity and objectivity of published research.
The American College of Chest Physicians confirmed receipt of a letter from Martin but declined to comment further on the matter.
Legal experts assert that medical journals, like news organizations, are protected by the First Amendment, safeguarding their editorial choices.
Summary based on 7 sources
Get a daily email with more Science stories
Sources

The New York Times • Apr 25, 2025
‘Vaguely Threatening’: Federal Prosecutor Queries Leading Medical Journal
The Boston Globe • Apr 24, 2025
New England Journal of Medicine targeted in US attorney inquiry
STAT • Apr 24, 2025
The nation’s top addiction researcher still has a job at the NIH — for now