Queensland's 'Adult Crime, Adult Time' Law Sparks Controversy Over Juvenile Justice and Human Rights
December 12, 2024
Liberal National Party MP Russell Field, a victim of crime, expressed support for the swift implementation of the laws, emphasizing the need for community safety.
Despite acknowledging the laws' incompatibility with human rights, the government justified them by citing what they described as 'exceptional' crime rates.
Attorney-General Deb Frecklington warned that the laws could disproportionately affect Indigenous children and noted potential conflicts with international standards.
Queensland's Liberal National government has enacted controversial youth justice laws known as 'adult crime, adult time,' allowing children as young as 10 to face adult penalties for serious crimes.
Premier David Crisafulli stated that these laws are a response to the juvenile crime crisis and aim to restore safety, fulfilling a promise made during the youth crime election campaign.
Under the new legislation, the maximum sentences for murder and manslaughter have increased from 10 years to a mandatory life term for juveniles, and children may receive the same maximum sentences as adults for 13 specific offences.
Notably, while the laws impose adult-length sentences for serious offences, they exclude sexual assault and rape, raising questions about the government's commitment to victims' rights.
The law received support from some center-left Labor opposition members, despite concerns from human rights advocates and internal debates about the political implications of their support.
Critics, including the Independent Human Rights Law Centre, argue that the law disproportionately affects Aboriginal children, who are already overrepresented in detention facilities.
The new laws require a third override of Queensland's Human Rights Act, further complicating the legal landscape surrounding juvenile justice in the state.
Queensland Human Rights Commissioner Scott McDougall criticized the laws, stating that equating children's treatment to that of adults reflects a societal failure.
Legal experts have warned that the tougher penalties may lead to fewer guilty pleas from children, resulting in longer trial processes and increased court delays.
Summary based on 5 sources
Get a daily email with more Australia News stories
Sources

BBC News • Dec 12, 2024
Queensland to impose adult prison sentences on children
The West Australian • Dec 12, 2024
Children to be sentenced as adults under new state laws