Queensland's 'Adult Crime, Adult Time' Law Sparks Controversy Over Juvenile Justice and Human Rights

December 12, 2024
Queensland's 'Adult Crime, Adult Time' Law Sparks Controversy Over Juvenile Justice and Human Rights
  • Liberal National Party MP Russell Field, a victim of crime, expressed support for the swift implementation of the laws, emphasizing the need for community safety.

  • Despite acknowledging the laws' incompatibility with human rights, the government justified them by citing what they described as 'exceptional' crime rates.

  • Attorney-General Deb Frecklington warned that the laws could disproportionately affect Indigenous children and noted potential conflicts with international standards.

  • Queensland's Liberal National government has enacted controversial youth justice laws known as 'adult crime, adult time,' allowing children as young as 10 to face adult penalties for serious crimes.

  • Premier David Crisafulli stated that these laws are a response to the juvenile crime crisis and aim to restore safety, fulfilling a promise made during the youth crime election campaign.

  • Under the new legislation, the maximum sentences for murder and manslaughter have increased from 10 years to a mandatory life term for juveniles, and children may receive the same maximum sentences as adults for 13 specific offences.

  • Notably, while the laws impose adult-length sentences for serious offences, they exclude sexual assault and rape, raising questions about the government's commitment to victims' rights.

  • The law received support from some center-left Labor opposition members, despite concerns from human rights advocates and internal debates about the political implications of their support.

  • Critics, including the Independent Human Rights Law Centre, argue that the law disproportionately affects Aboriginal children, who are already overrepresented in detention facilities.

  • The new laws require a third override of Queensland's Human Rights Act, further complicating the legal landscape surrounding juvenile justice in the state.

  • Queensland Human Rights Commissioner Scott McDougall criticized the laws, stating that equating children's treatment to that of adults reflects a societal failure.

  • Legal experts have warned that the tougher penalties may lead to fewer guilty pleas from children, resulting in longer trial processes and increased court delays.

Summary based on 5 sources


Get a daily email with more Australia News stories

More Stories