Australian Courts in Crisis: Fears of Wrongful Convictions Due to Unreliable Forensic Science

June 9, 2024
Australian Courts in Crisis: Fears of Wrongful Convictions Due to Unreliable Forensic Science
  • Expert opinion evidence handling in Australian courts is in crisis.

  • Concerns about the reliability of forensic science are raising fears of wrongful convictions.

  • Courts are criticized for admitting 'junk science' without proper validation.

  • Flawed methods, such as fingerprint comparisons and bite mark analysis, are particularly problematic.

  • Experts are calling for an explicit reliability standard for expert evidence.

  • There is a push to establish an independent panel for scientific guidance.

  • The creation of a Criminal Cases Review Commission is recommended to investigate potential wrongful convictions.

  • Urgent reform is needed to ensure the accuracy and fairness of the criminal justice system.

  • Focus should be on understanding the limitations of forensic science and not blindly accepting expert evidence.

Summary based on 3 sources


Get a daily email with more Science stories

More Stories