UK Commentator Detained, Visa Revoked in US Amid Free Speech Controversy Over Pro-Palestinian Views

October 27, 2025
UK Commentator Detained, Visa Revoked in US Amid Free Speech Controversy Over Pro-Palestinian Views
  • A British commentator, Sami Hamdi, was detained by US immigration authorities and had his visa revoked while in the US for a speaking tour, including an event at a Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR) in Florida.

  • The US Department of Homeland Security stated that Hamdi is in ICE custody pending removal, citing concerns over national security and terrorism support, with officials emphasizing that such actions are consistent with policies under the previous Trump administration.

  • Hamdi's detention appears to be related to his criticism of the Israeli government's actions in Gaza, which he expressed during his visit, amid heightened tensions following Israel's military offensive in Gaza.

  • Critics argue that the detention violates constitutional protections for free speech, especially given the broader context of increased enforcement measures targeting individuals critical of US Middle East policies.

  • Supporters, including Hamdi’s father and UK Muslim groups, have called for diplomatic assistance, emphasizing that press freedom should not be selective and that Hamdi has no known links to extremist groups.

  • Some social media figures, notably far-right activist Laura Loomer, claimed credit for Hamdi's detention, alleging her activism influenced authorities' actions against him.

  • The case has sparked controversy over free speech and the US government's approach to individuals expressing pro-Palestinian views, with legal battles ongoing over the constitutionality of detaining such individuals.

  • Hamdi's background includes studies at SOAS University of London, and he comes from a politically active family; his father is a Tunisian activist who fled Tunisia due to persecution.

  • Experts describe Hamdi as more than a journalist, suggesting he may be used by overseas extremist networks to influence American Muslims for ideological purposes.

  • The incident occurs amidst broader US actions such as revoking visas of Palestinian leaders and reviewing immigration policies, reflecting an intensified stance on immigration and national security.

  • The detention happened as the US continues to navigate a complex regional situation, including recent regional security concerns and ongoing conflicts in the Middle East.

Summary based on 15 sources


Get a daily email with more World News stories

More Stories