UK-France Migrant Return Highlights Border Scheme Challenges Amid Calls for Tougher Measures
November 10, 2025
The prime minister’s spokesperson framed the incident as proof the system works, pointing to biometrics at the border and a clear deterrent message to migrants.
The government emphasizes a broader aim to scale up removals and secure borders, signaling consequences for those attempting illegal entry.
A second migrant removed to France under the UK-France 'one in, one out' scheme has returned to the UK on a small boat, with Home Office confirmation of the arrival.
The individual was detained on detection and will be sent back to France as quickly as possible, reinforcing the scheme’s deterrent purpose.
The report is framed as breaking news with ongoing updates and a call to refresh for the latest information.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s team defended the scheme as effective, while critics call it unfair and ineffective.
Opposition critic Chris Philp argues the deal is an ineffective deterrent, noting very few removals and calling for tougher border measures and changes to appeals.
Critics describe the deal as a revolving door for illegal immigration and urge stronger border controls.
The scheme was announced in July by leaders of the UK and France as a coordinated, strengthened effort to disrupt crossings and bolster border security.
Officials say the total Sunday arrivals aren’t disclosed, but estimates show nearly 400 crosses alongside 1,772 people who crossed earlier in the week.
A Home Office message claims illegal working arrests have risen 63% to protect UK workers, tying into border security aims.
Shabana Mahmood is considering reforms modeled on Denmark to curb asylum claims and facilitate removal of those with no right to stay, including tighter family reunification rules.
Summary based on 14 sources
Get a daily email with more World News stories
Sources

The Guardian • Nov 10, 2025
Second man deported under ‘one in, one out’ scheme returns to UK on small boat
BBC News • Nov 10, 2025
Second migrant sent to France returns to the UK
The Independent • Nov 10, 2025
Another migrant re-enters UK by small boat after being removed to France
The Independent • Nov 10, 2025
Second migrant deported to France under ‘one in, one out’ scheme returns to Britain on small boat