Malcolm Turnbull Slams AUKUS Submarine Pact as Costly, Risky for Australia's Sovereignty

March 17, 2025
Malcolm Turnbull Slams AUKUS Submarine Pact as Costly, Risky for Australia's Sovereignty
  • Former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has sharply criticized the AUKUS nuclear submarines pact, describing it as a 'terrible' and 'unfair' deal that primarily benefits the United States.

  • He expressed concerns that Australia may not receive the promised submarines, raising doubts about the future of the trilateral security alliance.

  • Turnbull pointed out that Australia is investing $3 billion to support the US submarine industrial base without any guarantees of receiving submarines in return.

  • He noted that the deal, initiated by his successor Scott Morrison and supported by the Albanese government, requires Australia to purchase three to five Virginia-class submarines from the US at a staggering estimated cost of up to $368 billion.

  • The agreement stipulates that before any submarine transfer occurs, the US President must certify that it will not compromise the US Navy's undersea capabilities, which are currently deemed crucial.

  • This requirement raises further concerns, especially as the US Navy is currently operating with fewer submarines than desired.

  • Turnbull warned that the most likely outcome of AUKUS could leave Australia without its own submarines, forcing reliance on US submarines, which could compromise both sovereignty and security.

  • He argued that Australia is spending significantly more on the AUKUS deal compared to what it would have under the previous French contract, with a high likelihood of ending up without any submarines at all.

  • Despite assurances from Washington, London, and Canberra about the strength of the AUKUS alliance, anxiety is growing in Australia regarding potential delays or failures in receiving the submarines.

  • Turnbull's remarks came during an unscheduled interview at Parliament House, where he emphasized the perceived inadequacies of the AUKUS arrangement.

  • He criticized the 2021 agreement made by his successor, which abandoned a previous deal with France for submarines, lamenting the loss of sovereignty and security.

  • Ultimately, Turnbull believes that the deal is detrimental, costing Australia a significant amount of money while undermining its national interests.

Summary based on 3 sources


Get a daily email with more Australia News stories

Sources

Turnbull’s savage AUKUS take-down

news.com.au — Australia’s leading news site • Mar 16, 2025

Turnbull’s savage AUKUS take-down

AUKUS 'such a bad deal' for Australia: ex-Liberal PM

The West Australian • Mar 17, 2025

AUKUS 'such a bad deal' for Australia: ex-Liberal PM

More Stories