UK Data Bill Sparks Outcry Over AI Copyright Exemption; Artists, Lords Demand Stronger Protections
May 7, 2025
The Commons voted against the amendment with a tally of 287 against and 88 in favor, reflecting the strong opposition from artists and stakeholders.
AI companies have expressed concerns about transparency regulations, citing issues related to commercial security and competitiveness, further complicating the discussion around copyright.
The creative sector has rejected government concessions aimed at addressing copyright concerns, emphasizing the need for greater control and remuneration for creators.
Technology Minister Sir Chris Bryant has stated that while the creative industries should be compensated, the government prefers to wait for the results of a recent consultation before making legislative changes.
Lord Watson of Wyre Forest has highlighted the need for careful regulation to protect the UK music industry's future, acknowledging the risks posed by generative AI while recognizing the industry's historical embrace of technology.
As the Data (Use and Access) Bill progresses through Parliament, producer Giles Martin is urging the UK Government to enhance protections for artists against AI developers.
The proposed legislation includes a controversial exemption to copyright for training AI, which would require artists to opt out to prevent their work from being used, a move that has faced significant opposition from the creative community.
Despite calls for amendments to bolster copyright protections for creatives, the Bill passed the House of Commons on May 7, 2025, with the Government rejecting these proposals.
Legal actions have already been initiated by copyright holders against AI firms for alleged infringements, highlighting the ongoing tensions in the industry.
Although the Government offered some concessions, including an economic impact assessment, these were dismissed by both the creative industry and lawmakers as insufficient.
In response to the Bill's passage, peers in the House of Lords are planning to reintroduce amendments to strengthen copyright law, which could delay the Bill's progress.
Diginomica warns that ignoring the Lords' amendments could lead to irreversible consequences for UK copyright law, stressing the importance of protecting British creators.
Summary based on 26 sources
Get a daily email with more World News stories
Sources

The Independent • May 7, 2025
Data reforms move closer to becoming law amid calls to ‘protect artists’ from AI
The Independent • May 7, 2025
Producer Giles Martin says Government must do more to ‘protect artists’ from AI