A fire at the Chabad of Charlotte County in Punta Gorda, suspected as a hate crime, was quickly contained, with no injuries reported, but it caused significant damage to a classroom in the synagogue's community center.

Law enforcement arrested Blake Richard Hoover, a Florida man, on September 23, 2025, after evidence linked him to the arson, which involved spray-painting anti-Semitic symbols and setting the fire.

The incident occurred just before Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, heightening community concerns about safety during the High Holy Days.

Authorities described the fire as a criminal act and a hate crime, with investigations revealing that Hoover admitted to spray-painting a 'J' symbol, which is associated with anti-Semitic hate.

Evidence from Hoover’s residence, including spray paint cans, a gas can, and his car, supported his involvement, and detectives used license plate readers to place his vehicle near the scene.

Hoover was taken into custody on September 23, 2025, and is scheduled for arraignment on November 3 at the Charlotte County Courthouse, with bail set at $25,000, and a pre-trial detention request filed.

The damage from the fire includes broken windows, damaged walls, and smoke infiltration, rendering the building temporarily unusable, with repairs pending insurance assessments.

Community organizations like the Anti-Defamation League, Jewish Federation, and Secure Community Network issued statements condemning the attack and emphasizing the importance of safety and unity.

Local leaders and residents expressed strong support for the community, with some visiting the synagogue to celebrate the holiday despite the incident, and a reward of up to $3,000 was offered for information leading to Hoover's arrest.

The Chabad has launched a website to coordinate recovery efforts and solicit community assistance, reflecting resilience and determination to rebuild.

Authorities and community leaders are increasing patrols and security measures at places of worship across Sarasota and Charlotte counties to prevent further incidents.

The incident has sparked broader concerns about anti-Semitic violence and cyberattacks targeting Jewish communities, with the Pittsburgh Jewish Federation experiencing a major data breach around the same time.