Federal Judge Disqualifies Acting U.S. Attorney in Letitia James Probe, Citing Authority Issues
January 8, 2026
James’s office calls the ruling a meaningful safeguard for the rule of law and says it will persist in defending against political attacks tied to the administration.
A federal judge disqualified acting U.S. Attorney John Sarcone from overseeing investigations into Letitia James, ruling he lacked proper authority to issue subpoenas.
The decision raises questions about legality and legitimacy of investigations involving political figures and ongoing legal fights surrounding Donald Trump.
The ruling does not directly alter Virginia case charges but clarifies the authority limits of Sarcone’s role in New York investigations.
Related developments include James’s indictment in Virginia, tied to appointment issues of prosecutors handling that case.
The article notes ongoing debates about the legality of Trump-era appointments and cites similar disqualifications in other districts.
Background shows Sarcone’s roles during the 2016 campaign and his prior positions; the ruling could affect related subpoenas and investigations unless reissued under proper authority.
Despite the ruling, the White House maintains support for Sarcone, signaling ongoing controversy over his appointment and authority.
The decision fits a broader pattern of rulings scrutinizing Trump-era prosecutorial appointments and voiding official actions taken by those appointees.
The case sits within wider legal battles over Trump loyalists in prosecutorial roles, including appeals related to a civil fraud case against Trump and his company and a $464 million penalty that was vacated on appeal.
The ruling suggests prosecutors may reissue subpoenas through a properly authorized attorney, though it may not automatically affect all investigations by a designated prosecutor.
Legal analysts say the ruling is significant when an acting U.S. attorney is found lacking authority, noting subpoenas usually require broader authorization in routine cases.
Summary based on 13 sources
Get a daily email with more World News stories
Sources

Los Angeles Times • Jan 8, 2026
Judge disqualifies federal prosecutor in investigation into N.Y. Atty. Gen. Letitia James - Los Angeles Times
AP News • Jan 8, 2026
Federal prosecutor disqualified in Letitia James investigation | AP News
