Segal argues that perceived bias stems from editorial choices, coverage length, placement, and framing, and urges an oversight mechanism to test and improve reporting practices.

Segal points to specific issues, including a corrected Gaza infant casualties report and SBS reliance on Gaza ministry statistics, arguing corrections and accuracy affect trust.

Ombudsman findings note editorial breaches, with Middle East coverage drawing more complaints; some bias is seen as community-held views rather than systemic bias.

An erroneous ABC report claimed 14,000 Gaza babies would die in 48 hours, with a later online correction; the ombudsman found a breach of accuracy standards.

She pushes for the ABC and SBS to educate on anti-Semitism, adopt the IHRA definition as a tool, and avoid portraying Israel negatively, saying current coverage fuels distrust within the Jewish community.

Australia’s Special Envoy to Combat anti-Semitism, Jillian Segal, accuses the ABC of exacerbating anti-Semitism through its Gaza coverage, calling the reporting unbalanced and overly voiced from anti-Israel perspectives.

SBS and ABC issue statements defending their coverage and submissions, while protests outside the hearing reflect ongoing public contention.

Segal argues external oversight would safeguard public trust, while ABC editors defend the current ombudsman structure and ACMA oversight as effective.

ABC’s editorial director Gavin Fang defends editorial policies as impartial and accurate, noting audience feedback is considered in coverage decisions.

The inquiry precedes appearances by ABC and SBS, with both networks defending their journalism as evidence-based, fair, impartial, and aligned with Charter obligations.

ACMA’s role is debated; Segal calls ACMA “toothless,” while Lancaster notes no breaches found since Oct 2023, yet concerns over prioritization, impartiality, and balance remain.

Existing mechanisms include an ombudsman for both broadcasters, but Segal suggests regulator-like oversight similar to Ofcom with powers to direct corrections or investigations.