Apple Appeals to Supreme Court Over App Store Payment Dispute with Epic Games
September 14, 2026
Apple has filed its opening merits brief with the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn a contempt ruling in its Epic Games case, arguing that the injunction’s text did not clearly prohibit its app-commission structure or external-purchase links.
The original injunction required Apple to permit external links and calls to action directing users to third-party payment options; Apple later implemented commissions up to 27% on purchases routed through those links.
The DOJ contends contempt should be limited to conduct clearly covered by the injunction’s express terms, agreeing the 27% rate was not clearly prohibited but maintaining that Apple’s ‘plain button’ requirement (buttons plus links) was clearly prohibited.
Investors are focusing on commission rates as a driver of Services revenue and margins, influencing views on platform economics and potential settlements.
Industry observers discuss potential implications for other platforms and offer five predicted outcomes for the case, including timing, remand possibilities, and differing U.S. and EU regulatory paths.
Developers should note that zero commissions on external-link purchases remain during Supreme Court review and district court proceedings, with ongoing uncertainty about final rates.
Market attention includes steady iPhone demand and interest in the Duo dual-foldable, with mid-October availability and some Chinese buyers delaying purchases.
Analysts say Apple trades near the high end of historical valuation, with upside in Services potentially driving higher price targets.
The broader governance question remains: should remedies be enforced strictly by text or allow interpretation to prevent circumvention by dominant platforms?
Apple unveils Mac mini M6 with strong AI performance and a upgraded Mac Studio with M5 Ultra, highlighting ongoing hardware momentum alongside legal battles.
Key dates include the DOJ brief in late September, Supreme Court review in the 2026 term with decisions likely in early 2027, and EU regulatory changes taking effect in October 2026.
External-purchase fees remain central, with Apple proposing tiered rates in August 2026, including as low as 5% for Small Business Program apps.
Summary based on 13 sources
Get a daily email with more Tech stories
Sources
![Apple files Supreme Court brief challenging contempt ruling in Epic case [U]](https://cdn.brief.news/cdn-cgi/image/fit=contain,width=160/images/links/58582de710c562813afb9d06f31426a929b0ce88143d02621853ad411d7fd1e511dec9e58a76224d22318ec02c7cec3c39b6e38737c35c645bb668e89a66c20b.png)
9to5Mac • Sep 14, 2026
Apple files Supreme Court brief challenging contempt ruling in Epic case [U]
AppleInsider • Sep 14, 2026
Apple standing its ground in Epic's App Store fee suit
MacRumors • Sep 14, 2026
Apple Asks Supreme Court to Throw Out App Store Contempt Ruling
Tech Times • Sep 15, 2026
App Store Commission Limbo Enters New Phase as Apple’s Epic Merits Brief Opens SCOTUS Fight