The new play 'McNeal' by Ayad Akhtar features Robert Downey Jr. in his Broadway debut at Lincoln Center Theater, where he stars as Jacob McNeal, a celebrated novelist grappling with a troubled past and an obsession with artificial intelligence.

Exploring themes of artistic creation, the play delves into issues of invasion of privacy, originality, and the impact of AI on these concepts.

As the narrative unfolds, it raises provocative questions about creativity, plagiarism, and originality in an age increasingly influenced by AI.

However, the production has faced criticism for feeling overstuffed and lacking a coherent narrative, with supporting characters portrayed as one-dimensional and failing to resonate authentically.

Despite its engaging premise, the play struggles to maintain audience interest due to artificial interactions and a perceived lack of genuine character development.

While Downey's performance captures McNeal's charm and egotism, critics note he struggles with the nuanced emotional depth required in dramatic scenes.

McNeal is depicted as a troubled figure facing liver failure and alcoholism, with complex relationships, including a strained bond with his son and problematic behavior towards women.

The play also reflects modern societal issues, particularly in the context of the #MeToo movement, portraying McNeal as a flawed representation of a white male author.

A notable moment occurs during McNeal's acceptance speech for the Nobel Prize, where he reflects on AI's limitations in addressing mortality, sharing a personal story about his deceased wife.

The production features advanced special effects and a large projection of a smartphone, symbolizing technology's pervasive influence in McNeal's life and work.

Running through November 24 at the Vivian Beaumont Theater in New York, 'McNeal' lasts 1 hour and 40 minutes without intermission, but many critics agree it ultimately falls short of delivering a compelling and cohesive story.

Overall, 'McNeal' is viewed as a disappointing exploration of AI, prioritizing theoretical concepts over compelling drama.