The controversy surrounding the casting of a non-Asian actor in a show set in futuristic Seoul has reignited long-standing debates about race, representation, and opportunity for Asian American actors in theater.

An open letter signed by over 2,400 people, including prominent Tony winners, urges the show's creators to recast the lead with an Asian actor, reflecting widespread disappointment and frustration within the community.

Industry data shows Asian actors are severely underrepresented on Broadway, with only 3.7% of actors and just 2.8% of lead roles in musicals being Asian, highlighting systemic inequalities.

The controversy has affected cast members, including Helen J. Shen, who is dating the actor involved, and has sparked broader discussions about race, systemic inequality, and opportunity for Asian American actors in theater.

Social media reactions have been hostile towards the actor, with calls for him to withdraw from the role and criticism of the casting decision, fueling the ongoing debate.

An online open letter criticizes the casting decision, and social media users have expressed disappointment, urging the actor to step down amid ongoing damage to the show's reception.

The show, set in a futuristic Seoul with a predominantly Asian cast, was initially celebrated for its Asian-driven narrative and representation, with Darren Criss being the first Asian American to win a Tony for a leading role in a musical.

The production was based on a South Korea-developed story about helper robots, emphasizing the importance of Asian representation to its authenticity and message.

Industry figures and advocates call for respectful dialogue and understanding, emphasizing the importance of 'grace and kindness' when addressing these complex issues.

The show's creators stated that the characters are androids designed to be played by Asian performers, but the casting decision to choose a non-Asian actor undermines this vision and raises questions about cultural authenticity.

While the creators emphasized that roles were written to be played by Asian actors, critics argue that the casting choice diminishes the importance of cultural representation in the production.

Some industry figures, including playwright Michael R. Jackson, have defended artistic expression and dissent, criticizing social media mob mentality and supporting diverse perspectives.