In a recent interview, former Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon acknowledged that the debate over gender identity in Scotland has become increasingly irrational, particularly after Westminster blocked controversial reforms allowing transgender individuals to self-identify.

Sturgeon admitted her role in the loss of rationality during the gender recognition debate, noting that the case of transgender offender Isla Bryson significantly influenced public perception.

Isla Bryson, born Adam Graham, was convicted of raping two women and initially placed in a women's prison before being transferred to a male facility, which sparked widespread controversy.

In her interview, Sturgeon stated that individuals committing severe crimes against women might forfeit their right to self-identify by gender, although she later recognized this phrasing was unfortunate.

Critics, including SNP MSP Michelle Thomson, argued that Sturgeon's comments came too late and accused her of prioritizing the rights of trans individuals over women's rights during the legislative process.

Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay criticized Sturgeon for her previous support of gender self-identification laws, claiming she ignored warnings that such laws could be exploited by male predators like Bryson.

Findlay emphasized that if the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill had passed without intervention, it could have allowed rapists to legally declare themselves as women with state support.

Reflecting on the need to balance the rights of women and trans individuals, Sturgeon stated that these rights are not mutually exclusive and admitted she should have paused the self-identification legislation for further consideration.

Sturgeon expressed regret over her past comments regarding Bryson, acknowledging the need for clarity in addressing complex issues of gender identity.

During the interview, Sturgeon described Bryson as 'a biological male' and acknowledged that she should have been clearer on the topic of gender identity.

The interview revealed a notable shift in Sturgeon's stance on gender issues, indicating a possible reconsideration of her earlier policies and approach to gender identity legislation.

Sturgeon also reflected on her experiences during the 2014 Scottish independence referendum, revealing tensions with former SNP leader Alex Salmond regarding the drafting of the government's white paper on independence.