Scotland's First Minister Criticizes Elon Musk, Weighs Boycott of X Over Social Media's Role in Violence

September 16, 2025
Scotland's First Minister Criticizes Elon Musk, Weighs Boycott of X Over Social Media's Role in Violence
  • Swinney also emphasized the importance of responsible communication and highlighted his desire to keep Scotland welcoming and supportive of refugees, distancing from prejudiced rhetoric.

  • The article underscores the growing role of social media in modern politics, from campaign spending to voter engagement, even as traditional campaigning methods remain relevant.

  • Public figures face ethical and strategic decisions when choosing social media platforms, balancing outreach goals with potential reputational risks associated with harmful rhetoric.

  • There is a noticeable shift in news consumption from print and TV to online sources, with social media becoming increasingly dominant, although platforms like X still lag behind Facebook and YouTube.

  • Scotland’s First Minister John Swinney publicly criticized Elon Musk, calling him a 'malign influence' after Musk's involvement in a recent UK rally where violence occurred, and he expressed concern about Musk and other figures spreading prejudice and societal tension.

  • Swinney's decision to consider boycotting X reflects a broader debate about social media’s influence on politics, including issues of misinformation, responsible engagement, and platform moderation.

  • Despite the emergence of alternative platforms like BlueSky, Mastodon, and Threads, their impact remains limited, and siloed communities may deepen political polarization.

  • Transparency and alignment with personal and constituency values are crucial for politicians when deciding whether to engage with platforms like X.

  • Swinney and the SNP have historically relied heavily on social media for campaigning, but they are now questioning whether platforms like X are beneficial or harmful to political discourse.

  • While Swinney might eventually step back from X, his party will continue to use social media extensively, especially with an upcoming election on the horizon.

  • The debate around social media’s impact includes concerns about whether it accurately reflects society or distorts it, with some outlets like The Guardian abandoning the platform due to toxicity.

  • Swinney’s reaction highlights concerns among politicians about their public image and credibility when engaging with platforms associated with controversial or offensive content.

  • His concerns also extend to the influence of far-right extremism, which social media can amplify, linking this to recent violent events and political confrontations.

Summary based on 10 sources


Get a daily email with more UK News stories

More Stories