Menendez Brothers Face Resentencing: Could December Hearing Lead to Freedom After 34 Years?
October 30, 2024
The Menendez brothers, Erik and Lyle, are seeking clemency from California Governor Gavin Newsom, aiming for a reconsideration of their life sentences for the 1989 murders of their parents.
Los Angeles District Attorney George Gascón has stated that the brothers have served 34 years in prison and have participated in various educational and rehabilitation programs during their incarceration.
A Superior Court hearing for their resentencing is scheduled for December 11, 2024, although the judge may take additional time to deliberate, potentially delaying any decision.
The clemency request remains unconfirmed, as Newsom's office has indicated that pending applications are confidential.
Gascón's decision to support the brothers' clemency is viewed by some as a political maneuver, particularly as he faces a challenging reelection bid against Nathan Hochman, trailing by over 30 percentage points in polls.
This announcement has drawn mixed reactions; while some celebrities and supporters praise Gascón's stance, critics argue it may be an attempt to bolster his reelection prospects.
Despite the mixed reactions, all family members except one support the clemency request, emphasizing the emotional void created by the brothers' absence.
If granted clemency, the brothers would still face a parole board review before any potential release, which would include conditions like maintaining a job and avoiding drugs.
While family members advocate for the brothers' release based on their history of abuse, there is opposition from some relatives, including an uncle, highlighting the complex dynamics surrounding the case.
Should the judge approve resentencing, the case will move to the California Parole Board for a hearing, which could take up to six months to schedule, with Governor Newsom having 150 days to review the board's recommendation.
Family members have expressed hope for the brothers' release, with cousin Anamaria Baralt stating that a reunion would be a dream come true, especially during the upcoming holiday season.
Summary based on 27 sources
Get a daily email with more US News stories
Sources

Los Angeles Times • Oct 30, 2024
Lyle and Erik Menendez to return to court Dec. 11 - Los Angeles Times
NBC News • Oct 31, 2024
L.A. County DA Gascón supports clemency request for Menendez brothers