Maryland Parents Clash with Schools Over LGBTQ+ Books, Citing Religious Beliefs
April 18, 2025
A legal case in Montgomery County, Maryland, has emerged as parents oppose LGBTQ+ themed children's books in schools, citing religious objections.
The books in question, such as 'Prince and Knight' and 'Uncle Bobby’s Wedding', are designed for students in kindergarten through fifth grade and explore themes of love and identity.
Parents are seeking the right to withdraw their children from classes that include these books, arguing that the content conflicts with their religious beliefs about gender and sexuality.
The school district defends its curriculum, asserting that it does not indoctrinate students but instead introduces them to diverse perspectives, which is crucial for fostering inclusivity.
Supporters of the district warn that allowing opt-outs could lead to widespread religious exemptions from educational content, undermining the integrity of the curriculum and creating logistical issues for teachers.
The outcome of this case could set a significant precedent regarding the balance between education, parental rights, and religious freedom, with a Supreme Court decision expected by late June 2025.
PEN America, an advocacy group for literature, argues that the parents' actions resemble censorship and undermine the educational value of diverse stories.
While the plaintiffs are not demanding the removal of LGBTQ+ books, they are advocating for the option for parents to opt-out based on their religious beliefs.
Lower federal courts have previously sided with the school district, emphasizing the importance of teaching diverse subjects without accommodating individual religious objections.
The controversy began in 2022 when parents objected to the inclusion of LGBTQ-inclusive picture books in the curriculum, claiming their religious freedoms were at stake.
Initially, Montgomery County schools allowed opt-outs for certain materials but later revoked this option due to high absentee rates and classroom disruptions.
This case highlights a broader issue of book bans in schools, with over 10,000 books reportedly banned last year, raising concerns about censorship in educational settings.
Summary based on 13 sources
Get a daily email with more US News stories
Sources

AP News • Apr 19, 2025
Supreme Court case pits religious rights versus schools' use of LGBTQ books | AP News
Education Week • Apr 18, 2025
Supreme Court Faces Big Test on Religious Students' Opt-Outs From LGBTQ+ Books
WHYY • Apr 20, 2025
A prince and knight fall in love and the Supreme Court is asked to intervene