El Salvador Detention Sparks Outrage: Judge Calls Out Trump Administration's Handling of Garcia's Case
April 23, 2025
Garcia has been detained in El Salvador's harsh prison system, described as a 'tropical gulag,' raising serious concerns about his treatment and conditions.
Although he sought asylum, Garcia missed the filing deadline but was granted 'withholding of removal,' allowing him to stay in the U.S. temporarily.
Deputy Assistant Attorney General Drew Ensign filed a sealed motion seeking a stay on the judge's order for the administration to provide sworn testimony and documents about Garcia's return.
Kilmar Abrego Garcia, originally from El Salvador, illegally entered the U.S. in 2012 at the age of 16 and later settled in Maryland with his U.S. citizen brother.
Despite having no criminal convictions, Garcia's bond request was denied based on an unnamed informant's claims regarding gang affiliation.
A federal judge has accused the Trump administration of 'bad faith' in Garcia's deportation case, highlighting ongoing legal battles surrounding his status.
On April 23, 2025, a seven-day stay was granted in the case, indicating a potential shift in the contentious legal battle over his deportation.
Judge Paula Xinis granted the stay but maintained the requirement for daily updates from the government regarding efforts to facilitate Garcia's return.
The White House has not disclosed how it determined Garcia's alleged links to the MS-13 gang, raising questions about the basis for his deportation.
Democratic lawmakers, including Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen, argue that Garcia should return to the U.S. for a proper legal trial.
Advocates, including lawmakers, plan to keep pressure on the Trump administration regarding Garcia's case, with more visits to El Salvador expected.
Government attorneys have argued that disclosing the legal basis for Garcia's confinement could interfere with diplomatic discussions, complicating the case further.
Summary based on 47 sources
Get a daily email with more World News stories
Sources

The Guardian • Apr 23, 2025
Federal judge accuses White House of ‘bad faith’ in Kilmar Ábrego García case
The Independent • Apr 24, 2025
Trump-appointed judge orders government to ‘facilitate’ return of another deported asylum seeker sent to El Salvador
