Florida State University (FSU) is facing criticism for its athlete contracts, which include controversial clauses such as fines for lost equipment and penalties for injuries sustained during play.

Sports lawyer Darren Heitner has labeled these contracts as 'unconscionable,' emphasizing their one-sided nature and the lack of reasonable terms for athletes.

The contracts also prevent athletes from challenging decisions in court, forcing them into arbitration against the university's well-resourced legal team.

This situation raises ethical concerns about athlete exploitation, reflecting a broader issue in college football where the employer-employee relationship remains unclear.

As the NIL era progresses, FSU acknowledges that clarity and trust may become as important as financial compensation in attracting and retaining players.

Despite a disappointing 2-10 record last season, FSU is actively recruiting and currently ranks 13th nationally for its 2026 class, with notable recruits like four-star wide receiver Devin Carter.

The recent House settlement allows for up to $20.5 million in revenue sharing between schools and athletes, although how FSU will allocate these funds remains uncertain.

Urban Meyer has expressed concerns that the new contracts could harm recruiting efforts by giving the school excessive control over players.

Meyer also advises athletes to consult a lawyer to review NIL contracts, stressing the need for FSU to amend its agreements to better protect athlete rights.

In defense of its contracts, FSU claims they aim to provide clear expectations and a high-quality experience for student-athletes amidst the evolving landscape of collegiate athletics.

Meyer and former Heisman winner Mark Ingram have voiced disbelief over the implications of these contracts, highlighting the risks they pose for recruits.

Meyer predicts that if FSU continues with its current revenue-sharing strategy, it could lead to a decline in their football program as top recruits may avoid the school due to a lack of bargaining power.