The controversy was further fueled by Bove's previous role as a defense attorney for Donald Trump and his involvement in dismissing a corruption case against Mayor Adams.

Democrats criticized the committee's process, with Senator Booker condemning the proceedings as undermining democracy and allowing partisan influence to dominate judicial appointments.

During the hearing, Booker attempted to delay the vote, citing the whistleblower complaint and opposition from prosecutors, but was denied, leading him to shout for eight minutes after the vote proceeded.

The vote to advance Bove's nomination occurred despite protests, with Republicans dismissing Democratic concerns and emphasizing the need to expedite judicial confirmations amid partisan tensions.

On July 17, 2025, Senate Democrats staged a walkout during a Judiciary Committee hearing to protest the nomination of Emil Bove to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, citing concerns over his past actions and the process.

Despite the Democratic walkout, Republican senators advanced Bove's nomination, with all 12 Republican members supporting him and the committee proceeding under the leadership of Chairman Chuck Grassley.

Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ) led the protest, expressing outrage over the limited debate and the perceived undermining of democratic processes, especially given Bove's controversial background.

Booker and other Democrats raised issues about Bove's past actions at the Justice Department, including allegations that he suggested ignoring court orders related to immigration enforcement and the dropping of charges against New York City Mayor Eric Adams.

A whistleblower, Erez Reuveni, accused Bove of encouraging the Trump administration to defy court orders, a claim Bove has denied, but which intensified opposition to his nomination.

This episode highlights the deep partisan divisions over judicial nominations, with Democrats calling for more thorough vetting and Republicans prioritizing swift confirmations.

The controversy surrounding Bove reflects broader tensions in the Senate over judicial appointments, especially those linked to former President Donald Trump, and underscores ongoing battles over the judiciary.