Congress Divided as Democrats Push for Epstein Files Transparency Amid GOP Resistance
September 11, 2025
The Epstein case remains a hot-button issue in Congress, with Democrats led by Chuck Schumer pushing for the Department of Justice to release all related files to ensure transparency and accountability.
While the Senate effort to force disclosure was blocked by Senate Republicans, a similar initiative is advancing in the House through a discharge petition, with Democrats gaining additional support, including four Republicans, potentially paving the way for a vote later this month.
The controversy over Epstein's death in 2019 while awaiting trial continues to dominate congressional politics, especially as lawmakers seek to uncover the full extent of his connections and crimes.
Majority Leader John Thune criticized the move to block the transparency amendment, dismissing it as a 'stunt' and indicating it would be dismissed, reflecting the partisan divide on this issue.
The bill explicitly prohibits redactions based on reputational harm or political sensitivity, emphasizing a commitment to transparency and protecting victims' privacy.
The Trump administration's July decision not to release further Epstein investigation materials drew criticism from Schumer, who accused the government of lacking transparency.
The amendment was part of the National Defense Authorization Act, aiming to increase transparency regarding the Epstein investigation amid ongoing public and congressional pressure.
Senate Majority Leader Thune expressed skepticism about further action, citing trust in the DOJ’s efforts to release relevant information, though the issue remains contentious.
The House Oversight Committee previously obtained documents, including the infamous Epstein 'birthday book' with a signature allegedly from Trump, which Trump has denied as 'nonsense'.
The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform is conducting its own investigation into Epstein, with Democrats releasing images of a birthday greeting allegedly created by Trump for Epstein.
Senate Republicans, led by Thune, voted against the bill, effectively blocking its passage, with critics like Merkley accusing them of siding with powerful interests over justice.
The bill was supported by 24 Senators, including Schumer, and co-sponsored to shed light on Epstein’s crimes, with provisions to protect victims’ privacy and national security.
Summary based on 16 sources
Get a daily email with more US News stories
Sources

Yahoo News • Sep 10, 2025
Senate Republicans barely defeat effort by Democrats to force release of Epstein files
ABC News • Sep 10, 2025
Senate Republicans defeat Schumer effort to force vote on Epstein file release
Axios • Sep 10, 2025
Senate GOP blocks amendment to release Epstein files