ICE Arrests Under Trump: One-Third Had No Criminal History, Raising Concerns Over Enforcement Tactics

December 8, 2025
ICE Arrests Under Trump: One-Third Had No Criminal History, Raising Concerns Over Enforcement Tactics
  • ICE data show that in the first nine months of the Trump era, more than a third of about 220,000 arrests involved individuals with no prior criminal history, totaling around 75,000 people.

  • Overall, roughly 220,000 people were taken into ICE custody in that period, with more than a third having no criminal history, challenging the claim that enforcement targeted only the most dangerous offenders.

  • The report explores legal and policy context, along with criticisms of enforcement practices and responses from law enforcement, immigration lawyers, and protesters.

  • Ongoing coverage points to ICE operations in multiple cities and potential impacts on migrants and incidents during raids across places like Minneapolis, New Orleans, and Charlotte.

  • Border Patrol’s role expanded under the Trump administration, with detainees dispersed nationwide and debates about the scope and tactics of enforcement.

  • Border Patrol arrests are not included in these figures, leaving the full scope of arrests across DHS unclear.

  • Experts highlight the messaging-data gap, with analysts noting contradictions between public statements and the underlying data.

  • Detentions of U.S. citizens and allegations of racial profiling surface in discussions of enforcement practices.

  • Data shows large-scale deployments under names like Midway Blitz and Patriot 2.0, involving ICE, Border Patrol, and National Guard in urban areas, with an uptick after a Supreme Court ruling allowed race/ethnicity as a factor, though officials cited sanctuary-city policies.

  • The broader impact includes labor concerns from industry groups due to the crackdown, with uncertainty about deportations; about 22,959 left via voluntary departure and around 65,000 detained, while Border Patrol figures are not in the released data.

  • Policy analysts and media coverage frame the significance of arrest demographics versus stated goals, shaping public debate.

Summary based on 5 sources


Get a daily email with more US News stories

More Stories