St. Louis CITY SC Wins U.S. Open Cup in Penalty Shootout Drama Against Columbus Crew
October 22, 2026
St. Louis CITY SC claimed their first major trophy by winning the U.S. Open Cup in a 5-3 penalty shootout after a 0-0 draw with Columbus Crew through extra time.
Starting goalkeeper Roman Bürki was injured in the 69th minute and replaced by Ben Lundt, who stepped in after the head injury sustained by Bürki from a knee to the head earlier in the match.
Lundt delivered a decisive performance in the shootout, with St. Louis converting five penalties to seal the championship.
The match showcased tactical and squad changes for both teams, highlighting a dramatic, fresh approach this season.
Dante Polvara and Sean Zawadzki, Georgetown 2019 NCAA champions, faced each other, underscoring a link between college success and the pro game.
The article originates from USA TODAY/Reuters Connect, with standard disclosure regarding paid support and independent editorial decisions.
Columbus Crew’s managerial changes and strategic shifts, from Wilfried Nancy to Henrik Rydström and Laurent Courtois, framed the context and implications of the final.
Simon Becher and Damet emphasized the team’s belief, turning around a season with a clear vision to win the Open Cup.
Columbus Crew have rebuilt with signings like Brais Méndez and Anass Zaroury, aiming to capture their first Open Cup since 2002 and add to nine trophies overall.
The final unfolding is framed as a narrative of legacy and transformation, highlighting the home-field pressures for Columbus and the resurgence of St. Louis City SC.
Columbus Crew were pursuing their second Open Cup title in club history, marking their fourth final appearance and hosting status.
The match carries historical resonance tied to Lamar Hunt, with Columbus’ MLS roots adding significance to the final.
Summary based on 12 sources
Get a daily email with more US News stories
Sources

The Guardian • Oct 22, 2026
History comes home as St Louis City top Columbus Crew to win US Open Cup
CBS Sports • Oct 21, 2026
U.S. Open Cup live stream: How to watch Columbus Crew vs. St. Louis City SC, odds, TV channel
mlssoccer • Oct 22, 2026
CHAMPIONS! St. Louis CITY defeat Columbus Crew in US Open Cup final
Central Oregon Daily • Oct 21, 2026
Columbus Crew vs St. Louis City US Open Cup final: How to watch, starting lineups