Norway Winter Test Reveals EV Range Discrepancies: Polestar 3 Shines, Tesla Falls Short
January 19, 2025
Norway recently conducted a winter range test for electric vehicles, evaluating the performance of 24 new models under challenging conditions.
The Polestar 3 emerged as a top performer, achieving a real-world range of 330 miles, comparable to the Tesla Model 3, which has a claimed range of 348 miles.
In contrast, other EVs, such as the Peugeot E-3008, significantly underperformed, with some models experiencing range drops of up to 106 miles below their claimed figures.
Cold weather drastically affects electric vehicle range, making it a critical factor for consumers, especially in Scandinavian countries where such tests are common.
The results of this winter test are expected to influence consumer perceptions and encourage manufacturers to provide more honest representations of their vehicles' capabilities.
Recent advancements in battery technology have enabled competitors like Audi and Zeekr to close the gap with Tesla, which has seen relatively stagnant offerings.
Interestingly, four out of the top five EVs in the test were made in China, showcasing the strong performance of Chinese manufacturers in the electric vehicle market.
Conducted in mild winter temperatures around 5°C (37°F), the test revealed concerning range losses, particularly the Peugeot's 31% drop.
While many models showed a range loss between 10% to 20%, the results raised questions about Tesla's performance, especially given its previous leading rankings.
Tesla ranked 21st out of 24 cars for range accuracy in the test, despite having one of the longest claimed ranges, highlighting discrepancies between expected and actual performance.
This test underscored the notable discrepancies between WLTP and EPA range estimates, emphasizing the need for more accurate reporting from manufacturers.
Technology analyst Rob Enderle expressed concerns about overstated range claims, advocating for consistent and realistic range reporting across all manufacturers.
Summary based on 4 sources
Get a daily email with more Tech stories
Sources

Electrek • Jan 17, 2025
The top electric cars in this winter range test will surprise you
Carscoops • Jan 19, 2025
Winter EV Range Test: 19 Cars Promised Over 300 Miles, But Only 4 Delivered | Carscoops
City Magazine • Jan 19, 2025
Polestar 3: the silent star of the winter test reaches 2025 - in which 24 electric cars participated